Aims Ability Achieved

 

Aims
Ability
Achieved

Delegation is about passing on a task that you would normally do yourself. Teamwork is about identifying what needs to be done and sharing the tasks most appropriately.

Aims

When delegating a task to another person is it clear what the aims are and are they understood by all people involved?

Delegation does not need to involve telling someone what to do. Often it is better to discuss what is to be achieved by the team as a whole and then ask that person how they will contribute. People who have ownership of tasks will be more motivated and feel in more control of the work.

Ability

Does the person carrying out the allocated work have the ability to complete the task and the resources to be able to complete the role. Someone who is very capable may just need to understand what the broad objectives are and will then complete the work without further input. Someone with little experience may need closer supervision and support on a regular basis.

Achieved

Agree a time period in which to review the progress together. Three months is often a good period for non urgent tasks or larger projects. Particularly if the person is capable and will take the project forward. At the review point discuss if the task been achieved or does more need to be done. What is the next objective.

Source: The outline for Aims Ability and Achieved is a summary of the “three rules” ably described with examples by Valerie Iles on page 7 of her book Really Managing Health Care 2006 Open University Press

 

Quality Improvement

Our aim?
When are we there?
What changes?

The science of quality improvement (improvement science) is developing. It sits at the interface between improving practice in a practical real world way and collecting evidence of improvement. Quality improvement is said to include and build on from the elements of audit and evidence based medicine by adding in a regular review over time to assess the impact of interventions. There is an evolving “Plan Do Study Act” cycle which is preceded by three specific questions.

  • What are we trying to accomplish?
  • How will we know that a change is an improvement?
  • What are the changes we can make to deliver improvement?

Key principles are to involve all relevant parties, to keep things focused, and to start with a small number of people and a realistic change

Our aim?

This aim statment should be clear and relatively brief. It should include “how good” and “by when”. To ensure all doctors in training have an educational supervisor within 3 months. The aim should be SMART – Specific Measurable Achievable Realistic and Timed.

When are we there?

Measures of change can be outcome, process or balanced. An outcome measure might include the opinion of the customer, patient or staff. It may be satisfaction or it could be a result. A process measure looks at the working of the system. A Balancing measure looks at unintended consequences.

What changes?

It is best not to presuppose the changes required but considering them can help design the measures to show change. There are classifications of change that can be used as an aide memoire or to help planning. These are outlined in the implementation guide of the London Deanery. Examples of categories include reducing waste, improving workflow, customer interface and mistake proofing. Each category has specific subheading of between 3 and 15 approaches.

A run chart gives an overview of the procress and is a method which introduces some rigor in the process. The measure is plotted against time and the pattern determines the impact of the changes. Four rules help to confirm the test is reliable. The relationship of serial results and the median of the previous results gives evidence of change.

Rule 1 A point outside the control limits set by the data. 3 standard deviations is 99% of the data
Rule 2 Sevenpoints are above or below the previous mean line
Rule 3 Any unusual pattern or trend
Rule 4 Middle third differs from out third.

Quality Improvement Models

Total Quality Management
Kaizen
Six Sigma
Continuous Quality Improvement

Several models for quality improvement have emerged from manufacturing industry and can be applied to improving patient care pathways or education. Examples of effective application exist within the NHS. The search is on for the most efficient way to produce focused improvements. Getting that balance between time invested and effective change. The key appears to be gathering feedback from, and then checking proposals, with a representative person in every step in the patient care pathway.

Total Quality Management

Total Quality Management (TQM) is a review of the whole pathway or process from start to the end product. It involves discussion with everyone related to that process, who all contribute suggestions for improvements.

The example is a failing American television manufacturer who was taken over by a Japanese company. The new owner took on a process of TQM and reduced the failure rate of televisions from 5% to 0.2%. They were able to close the “reworking line” which dealt with the faulty televisions and convert these savings to a profit.

Kaizen

Kaizen is a Japanese phrase that means “change good” in English. It is a process of incremental change by every worker who submits suggestions for improvement. It is a managing change system. Every suggestion is reviewed with a plan and if it helps the suggestion is adopted. One business generated 127 suggestions per worker with a total of 200,000. Of these 90% were adopted.

Six Sigma

Six Sigma has been described as TQM on steroids. Like TQM if involves everyone in a review of the pathway or process with the aim of reducing errors. Executive leads encourage and guide this review.

A DMAIC approach is followed: Define Measure Analyse Improve Control. This is an advance on the Plan Do Study Act (PDSA) cycle. Define looks at customer goals. Control involves documentation and training to reduce errors.

An example is Victoria Health in New Jersey USA. They undertook a Six Sigma programme for heart failure care. Hospital stay was reduced from six to four days, patient education increased from 27% to 80% and consistency of chart records increased form 67% to 93%.

Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI)

Also know as “lean” CQI has been applied in universities and the NHS with training courses available to those interested. The steps involve:

  • Seeing the “customer” to determine what is wanted
  • Mapping the activities to identify areas of inefficiency and waste
    Improvement
  • Review

Suggestions for change are generated within workshops and plotted on a “Pain Gain” chart to help decide which are tackled. Vertical axis is from “High Benefit” to “Low Benefit”. Horizontal axis from “Hard to implement” to “Easy to implement” Each axis intersects in the centre as a cross.

Project teams are established to plan and implement each proposal with review by the team and a CQI board which co-ordinates, updates and maintains momentum.

Source: Information on CQI is from Dr Mary Beech GP training lead in the Wales Deanery based on work with the Cardiff University Lean unit, which reviewed the training of doctors. Thank you
Information on quality improvement models is from Clare Whittle Knowledge Transfer Partnership Associate Severn School of primary care Sept 2010, Thank you.

Team Orientation

 

Who is in the team
What are their skills and preferences
What is the route of contact

When a team is established effective working together can be facilitated by simple steps outlined below and illustrated in the layout of the sheet below. This was first designed for the 2012 London Olympics to help with the roles of the medical team covering the hockey pitch.

Who is in the team

Just a list of names and ideally face to face introductions. It may be better to write these down for easier recall.

What are their skills and preferences

Everyone has a preference about their role. This preference may be hidden amongst other discussion and more pressing tasks. Knowng what each others preferences are enables each person to identify what their own role migh tbe within.

What is the route of contact

Once you have a network of people who relate to one area of work it becomes an issue to ensure any emerging problems are identified earlier, and dealt with locally. For the 2012 Olympics medical team the following layout was adapted with the patient in the middle and the anaesthetist at the head of the sheet.

Team Orientation - route of contact document example

Tips for Leadership

 

Support network
Prepare prior
Interpersonal skills

Dr Clare Gerada, the first female chair of the Royal College of General Practitioners for 50yrs, recalls an advise sheet given to her in 2010 entitled “survival”. This is published in the British Medical Journal 30th January 2021. The tips she gives are as follows:

Support network

Find like minded people in the organisation to give feedback and early warning of problems. Create a support group of friends or colleagues and a mentor or coach/counsellor. If things go badly your group should support first and share advice later.
Ensure enough time one to one with key people of influence, and accept discussions will take place in other settings

Prepare

Consider and write down your aims before the meetings. Decide the red lines you will not cross based on your values. Ensure key points are recorded for later reference. Be a subtle self publicist.

Interpersonal skills

Deal with overt discrimination by successive questioning and keep cool. “Could you clarify exactly what you mean”.
If bullied step back, recognise and look at how to counter it, as if in a consultation. In public meetings, speak steadily, calmly and monitor your body language. Avoid gossip by keeping personal issues to yourself.
Use a reflective diary to review, learn and understand. Things won’t always go right, don’t beat yourself up, accept it is normal to be upset, be open about it and use the learning to build on the experience. Give yourself time to recover after difficult meetings or media discussions.

Source: Clare Gerada Tips for surviving leadership BMJ 2021;372;n195 30th January